5 Ways People Think They’ll Save Money, But They Really Don’t

From Baby Boomer to Gen Z, saving money is a trendy topic. It is widely popular amongst people of every income level. After all, it is a sound financial decision. 

Numerous tips, tricks, and advice on saving money are readily available. While most of them are great, not all apply to your situation. Here are five ways people think they’ll save money, but they don’t.

Annual Subscription

The discounted annual subscriptions are usually cheaper than paying monthly. But when you put things into perspective, it might be costing you more. 

For example, Amazon Prime subscription costs $14.99 per month. But the annual subscription, currently priced at $139, will give a $40 savings. 

But do you use Amazon prime every month? 

According to the Diffusion Group, 79% of prime subscribers sign up for free shipping. If you’re using Prime benefits for less than nine months, you’re already losing money with an annual subscription. 

The products on the Amazon marketplace are comparatively expensive. Rachana Shakya, a small business owner and a seller on Amazon, says, “it’s almost impossible to break even if your profit margins are less than 300% on the platform. Consumers also play Amazon’s steep selling fees .” Consumers lose money if they don’t shop around.

Another scenario where this conventional money-saving trick will not work is Gym membership. According to the research, Americans spend $1.3 billion on an unused gym memberships. Those who are unsure if they’ll stay motivated on their New year’s resolution to get fit should not sign up for a long-term contract. 

Warehouse club membership

The warehouse club membership is a paid benefit for shoppers to save money by buying in bulk. The US warehouse club and supercenter is a billion-dollar industry generating 40 Billion monthly retail sales according to Statistica. Costco and Sam’s Club are the leaders in this field.

There are savings to bulk purchases and the club’s product line, but is buying in volume essential? Or are we simply buying them for the discount? 

Getting more for less is good when necessary, or they’ll lose value. Data suggests that 80% of Americans discard consumable food due to misinterpretation of expiry labels. Chances are we buy more than we can consume and contribute to spoilage.

Warehouse clubs have various membership levels ranging from $45 to $120. The executive membership pays for itself through points and cash backs. But do you shop enough to accumulate points? 

For a $120 membership, you must spend $6,000 to cover the fee. While you can easily spend $6,000 a year, a $500 expense in one warehouse every month does not apply to everyone. The shoppers’ club is not your everyday shopping location. Unlike in local grocery stores, you cannot find all the items you need in the warehouse club.

Using cash instead of Credit Card

If you ever listen to the Dave Ramsey show, you’ll hear it a million times on why he prefers cash for all purchases and how credit cards will make us broke. 

But are credit cards the culprit of the financial crisis?

Saving money with cash purchases is a method of forced savings by limiting access to cash. It might work in some cases, but the best way to save money is by being intentional. 

Handling cash is inefficient and inconvenient. The changes after purchase are cumbersome to manage and easy to lose. Unlike credit cards, paper money is not secure. If you lose it, you can’t get it back. You’re also losing cashback rewards, fraud protection, and some of the benefits credit cards offer. 

You’ll have an online record of all spending for expense tracking and financial planning with a credit card. You can perform online as well as in-store contact-less transactions. It is beneficial while traveling.


Buying a home is a substantial long-term expense. The mortgage is usually a 15 to a 30-year term. Therefore, everyone wants to save money when possible. Home refinance helps you save money by reducing loan terms or monthly premiums. Depending on the refinance contract, it may not make any difference or even lose money. 

Refinance, like every home mortgage, comes with a closing cost. It is usually 3%-6% of the loan amount to cover loan origination, underwriting, and administrative fees. The closing price is never free, not even for a no-closing-cost mortgage refinance. It either goes into the loan, or you have to pay upfront. Depending on the interest rate deduction, the closing cost could be significant enough to eat up all the savings.

If the loan extends to the original term, the refinance will lose you money. It will solely reduce monthly payments, which is beneficial if you struggle to keep up with the current installments.

For example, a $300,000 home at 20% down with a 5% interest rate on a 30-year loan term costs $223,813.88 in interest only. The monthly payment on the loan is $1,288.37. You’d have paid $109,825.59 interest in 10 years. If you were to refinance the remaining loan after ten years at a 4.5% interest rate for the next 30 years, your monthly premium would drop to $973.96, but you’d pay a total of $158,402.96 in interest on the refinanced loan. Therefore, you’d pay $268,228.55 (higher than the initial interest ) with a lower interest rate and extend the loan term.     

Shopping In-Store than online

Shopping in-stores rather than online is one of the rare but recommended personal finance advice. The theory is that the drive to stores will demotivate people from going shopping altogether. While online shopping has easy access from the comfort of your bedroom, the FirstInsight report shows impulse purchases are more common during in-store shopping. People tend to spend more in stores. The trend may shift in the future with technology, but currently, retail therapy still contributes to more spending than internet shopping.

One of the significant drawbacks to in-store shopping is the missed cost-savings opportunity on products. Some online products are inexpensive because no in-person customer support team and building overheads are required. 

Price comparison is easier on online products that help find cheaper alternatives. You’ll also have access to online discount hunting applications like Capital One Shopping and Honey that search and apply discounts automatically without having to clip coupons. 

Final Thought  

Saving money is usually plain and simple, but sometimes it depends on shoppers’ situation. What may seem like a cost-saving might end up becoming less economical. It does not hurt to analyze the money-saving advice you receive for a minute or two and ask yourself how it applies to you.